Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Boro Park, Brooklyn
Handcrafted pies, family recipes, neighborhood love — since 1972.
"Every pie is made with the same love
as the very first one we ever baked."
Since 1972, AJ's Pizzeria has been feeding Boro Park families from the same corner on Fort Hamilton Pkwy. What started as a small neighborhood pie shop has grown into a beloved landmark — three generations of Brooklyn history baked into every crust.
We still use the same dough recipe. The same sauce. The same hand-stretched technique. Because when something is perfect, you don't change it — you just keep making it with love.
From kids who grew up eating our BBQ chicken pie to grandparents who still come in every Friday night — AJ's isn't just a restaurant. It's home.
First dates, family dinners, late-night slices after the game — we've seen it all.
From office lunches to milestone birthdays and block parties — AJ's brings 54 years of flavor to your event. No event too small, no crowd too big.
Full trays of any pie. Perfect for parties of 10 to 200+
Sunday-style pasta trays, salads, and Italian starters
Oreo zeppoles, cannolis, and house-made sweets
Weddings, milestones, corporate — we handle it all
"The BBQ chicken pie is UNREAL. I've been coming here since I was a kid with my dad and now I bring my own kids. This place is Brooklyn history."
"The Oreo zeppoles are the best thing I've ever eaten. I drive 40 minutes from Jersey just for these. No joke."
"Margherita is absolutely perfect — fresh ingredients, perfect char on the crust. These guys have been doing it right since before I was born."
Join 67+ happy customers — and counting.
54 years of feeding the families, workers, students, and dreamers of this corner of Brooklyn.
We've been on the same corner for 54 years. We're not hard to find.
| Monday – Thursday | 11am – 10pm |
| Friday | 11am – 11pm |
| Saturday | 12pm – 11pm |
| Sunday | 12pm – 9pm |
Questions about catering, large orders, or private events? Drop us a line.